Key West, Florida, renowned for its vibrant culture and stunning beaches, also boasts a culinary scene that’s as diverse as it is delicious. From fresh seafood to international flavors, the island offers a range of dining experiences that cater to every palate. Whether you’re craving casual bites or fine dining with a view, here are the nine best places to eat in Key West.
Blue Heaven
Nestled in the heart of Key West, Blue Heaven is more than just a restaurant; it’s a culinary institution with a quirky charm that captures the essence of the island. This historic spot, once a haven for Bahamian roosters, now beckons diners with its lush gardens and vibrant atmosphere. Blue Heaven is renowned for its Key West pink shrimp and delectable banana bread, making it a must-visit for both locals and tourists seeking an unforgettable dining experience.
Santiago’s Bodega
For those who love the art of sharing plates and savoring international flavors, Santiago’s Bodega offers a cozy retreat in the heart of Key West. This tapas-style restaurant invites guests to indulge in an array of small plates, from Spanish classics to creative interpretations of global cuisines. The vibrant atmosphere and warm hospitality make Santiago’s Bodega a favorite among food enthusiasts looking to enjoy an evening of culinary exploration.
Louie’s Backyard
Perched on the edge of the Atlantic Ocean, Louie’s Backyard offers an unparalleled dining experience with panoramic views that rival its exquisite menu. Known for its fresh seafood and creative American dishes, this waterfront gem combines culinary excellence with breathtaking scenery. Whether you’re dining indoors or on the deck overlooking the ocean, Louie’s Backyard promises a memorable meal infused with Key West’s coastal charm.
Pepe’s Cafe
Step back in time at Pepe’s Cafe, Key West’s oldest restaurant, where classic American breakfast and comforting dishes have delighted diners since 1909. Tucked away in a historic building, Pepe’s Cafe invites guests to savor hearty meals amidst charming surroundings. Whether you’re starting your day with fluffy pancakes or enjoying a leisurely lunch of homemade soups and sandwiches, Pepe’s Cafe promises a taste of Key West’s rich culinary heritage.
Don't Settle for Ordinary.
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR UNIQUE WEB-STORIES NEWSLETTER AND ELEVATE YOUR READING GAME.
Latitudes
Accessible only by boat, Latitudes offers an exclusive dining experience on Sunset Key, where every meal is accompanied by breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico. This upscale restaurant specializes in fresh seafood and contemporary American cuisine, prepared with a focus on quality and flavor. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply savoring a sunset dinner, Latitudes promises an unforgettable culinary journey in an idyllic island setting.
Garbo’s Grill
For a taste of Key West’s casual dining scene, look no further than Garbo’s Grill, a beloved food truck known for its flavorful tacos, burritos, and burgers. Tucked away in a corner, this hidden gem attracts food enthusiasts with its inventive menu and laid-back vibe. Whether you’re enjoying a quick bite at one of the outdoor tables or grabbing takeout to enjoy on the go, Garbo’s Grill delivers a delicious experience that captures the essence of Key West’s culinary creativity.
Nine One Five
Located in a historic Victorian house on Duval Street, Nine One Five offers a sophisticated dining experience amidst stylish surroundings. Known for its contemporary American cuisine and impeccable service, this restaurant combines elegance with a relaxed ambiance. Whether you’re dining in the chic interior or on the charming patio, Nine One Five invites guests to indulge in a culinary journey that celebrates Key West’s vibrant spirit and culinary innovation.
El Meson de Pepe
Immerse yourself in the flavors of Cuba at El Meson de Pepe, where authentic cuisine and lively entertainment converge in the heart of Mallory Square. This vibrant restaurant offers outdoor seating with views of the bustling square, creating a lively atmosphere enhanced by live music and dancing. From classic Cuban dishes to refreshing mojitos, El Meson de Pepe invites diners to experience the island’s cultural heritage through its delicious food and spirited ambiance.
The Stoned Crab
Situated along the waterfront, The Stoned Crab offers a laid-back dining experience where fresh seafood takes center stage. Known for its signature stone crab claws and locally sourced delicacies, this casual restaurant combines quality ingredients with a relaxed atmosphere. Whether you’re enjoying a seafood feast with friends or sipping cocktails by the water, The Stoned Crab promises a memorable meal infused with Key West’s coastal charm.
